Skip to main navigation Skip to search Skip to main content

An Alternative Approach To Identifying Councils 'At Risk': A Rejoinder To Bob Walker And Stewart Jones

  • Brian Edward Dollery

    Research output: Contribution to journal › Article › peer-review

    Abstract

    Murray and Dollery (2005) developed a statistical model that sought to determine whether the key performance indicators (KPIs) published by the NSW Department of Local Government (DLG) could adequately predict the 'at risk' status of local councils that had partly been assigned to councils on the basis of these KPIs. Walker and Jones (2006) contend that Murray and Dollery (2005) were (i) attacking a 'straw man' by erroneously misinterpreting DLG procedures and (ii) their model exhibited various econometric problems. In addition, Walker and Jones (2006) developed an alternative model that defined municipal sustainability as the ability to maintain service provision at pre-existing levels. This Rejoinder addresses the criticisms raised by Walker and Jones (2006) and assesses their alternative model. It is argued that such a concept is more relevant to the public sector than conventional 'financial distress' prediction models. The estimates provided by NSW local councils of the cost of upgrading infrastructure to a satisfactory condition were used as a proxy for levels of distress. Independent variables were selected from a range of KPIs published by the DLG. While MD found that most of the DLG performance indicators were not statistically significant in their model (and therefore not useful discriminators of council distress), this study reaches different conclusions using a different selection of indicators, and a distress variable construct more appropriately linked to service delivery.
    Original languageEnglish
    Pages (from-to)358-361
    JournalEconomic Papers
    Volume25
    Issue number4
    Publication statusPublished - 2006

    Keywords

    • Specialist Studies in Education

    Fingerprint

    Dive into the research topics of 'An Alternative Approach To Identifying Councils 'At Risk': A Rejoinder To Bob Walker And Stewart Jones'. Together they form a unique fingerprint.

    Cite this